I agree with doc. Wallpapers do have a big say in what's downloaded, and what's not. However, I've tried not paying attention to the wallpaper, and only looking at the actual theme - the popup, the bar (if there is one), etc. I'm not sure about the editor's choice thing for one reason, though. The editor is only one person. He has his likes and dislikes. Now, just because he/she dislikes a theme, doesn't mean it's a good theme. It could be a really nice theme, just not his cup of tea.